Systematic Biases in Tropical Drought Monitoring: Rethinking SPI Application in Mesoamerica’s Humid Regions

Abstract

The Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI) is widely used to determine drought severity worldwide. However, inconsistencies exist regarding its application in warm, humid tropical climatic zones. Originally developed for temperate regions with a continental climate, the index may not adequately reflect drought conditions in tropical environments where rainfall regimes differ substantially. This study identifies the following two principal reasons why the traditional calculation method fails to characterize drought severity in tropical domains: first, the marked humidity contrast between the consistently humid rainy season and the rest of the year, and second, the diverse drought types in tropical regions, which include both long-term and short-term events. Using data from meteorological stations in Mexico’s humid tropics and comparing them with temperate regions, the study demonstrates significant discrepancies between SPI-based drought classifications and actual precipitation patterns. Our analysis shows that the abundant precipitation during the rainy season causes biases in longer time scales integrated into multivariate drought indices. Considerations are established for adapting the SPI for decision makers who monitor drought in humid tropics, with specific recommendations on time scale limits to avoid biases. This work contributes to more accurate drought monitoring in tropical regions by addressing the unique climatic characteristics of these environments.